Skip to Content

NGC 4631 – Whale Galaxy

The Whale galaxy is a fascinating astrophotography target in the constellation Canes Venatici.  This barred spiral galaxy has interesting star-forming regions throughout, and it is a personal favorite of mine.

The Whale Galaxy

NGC 4631 – The Whale Galaxy

In April 2017, I captured my latest version of the Whale Galaxy using an ASI071MC-Cool CCD Camera and my Explore Scientific ED102.  I also tried out Astro Photography Tool for the first time and was extremely happy with the results.

The version of the image shown in the video below includes over 5 hours worth of total integrated exposure time.  These were shot over the course of two nights (April 23, 24) and were stacked and processed using my standard deep sky workflow.

Let’s Photograph the Whale Galaxy – Video:

This is one of the highest quality deep sky astrophotography images I have taken to date.  The cooled sensor in the ZWO camera provided virtually noise-free images.  View the full resolution version on AstroBin.

NGC 4631 and NGC 4657 – The Whale and the Hockey Stick

The Whale and the Hockey Stick

The Whale and the Hockey Stick Galaxies

Photo Details:

Dates Photographed: April 23-24 2017
Total Exposure: 5 Hours, 20 Minutes

64 x 300-second exposures
15 Darks, 15 Bias, 15 Flats

Stacked and Registered in DSS
Astro Photography Tool for Camera Control
Post Processing In Photoshop


Below, you will find my previous version of NGC 4631, using a smaller telescope and DSLR Camera.  If you own an 80mm refractor telescope, you can expect similar results using a modified DSLR camera.

NGC 4631 – The Whale Galaxy

Astrophotography telescope

This was a project I worked on over several nights in May 2016.  I began by shooting short exposures during the waning gibbous moon phase, capturing light frames with heavy moon glow.  As the days went on, and clear nights continued, my exposure time increased.

I kept attacking this galaxy night after night, adding about an hour’s worth of good data each time.  The contrast in my images continued to improve each night as I got closer and closer to new moon.   This is the result

This is the result of almost 4 hours of exposure. It was actually quite an enjoyable experiment to add an extra hour at a time, stack the data and process. Frame after frame, the signal to noise ratio improved, and the details of the galaxy emerged.

 

Astrophotography Details:

Total Exposure: 3 hours, 52 min. (76 frames)

Imaged: May 24, 26, 30, 31.
May 24 – 150s ISO 800
May 26 – 180s ISO 800
May 30 – 180s ISO 1600
May 31 – 210s ISO 1600

 

Set Up, Tear Down & Repeat

basic astrophotography setup

Clearly (pardon the pun!) I had a long stretch of clear nights, allowing me to re-visit the Whale galaxy night after night with my DSLR and telescope.  It’s times like this when I wish I had a backyard observatory, rather than setting everything up and tearing down every time.

My own observatory?

At my current property, it is unlikely that I will build a permanent pier to mount my telescope.  The light pollution is just too severe to begin construction of a small roll-off roof observatory.  I’ll save that dream for another time, and some darker skies.

4 Nights if Imaging in DSS

Have a look at the frame rotation between each imaging session.  If you couldn’t tell, I did not use any plate-solving software during this project.  I have heard good things about Astro Tortilla!

Stacking multiple nights in Deep Sky Stacker

My stack of 4 night’s worth of frames in DSS

Equipment Used

Camera: Canon 450D (modified)
Telescope: Explore Scientific ED80
Mount: Skywatcher HEQ5 Pro
Guide Scope: Orion Mini 50mm
Guide Camera: Meade DSI Pro II
Acquisition Software: Backyard EOS, PHD Guiding
Processing: Adobe Photoshop CC, Noel Carboni’s Tools


Astrophotography Processing Tips

The most challenging aspect of processing this image was not the galaxies small size, it was the large area of black space in the frame.  When you photograph a deep-sky object containing large areas of empty black space you must pay special attention to noise reduction and gradients.

Gradients and vignetting are major issues to tackle when imaging from my light polluted backyard in the city.  Even though the signal to noise ratio improved as I stacked more exposures together, a heavy gradient with wavy discoloration remained throughout the image.  Once again, the Gradient Xterminator plugin for Adobe Photoshop was a life saver.

I ran several iterations until I was able to achieve a consistent black-point of about R:18, G:18, B:18)

How to remove gradients in Photoshop

The whale galaxy through 80mm telescope

Reducing Star Size

I personally enjoy images with small, colorful stars.  This can be tough to master, as the initial curve stretch alone can brighten and bloat the stars in your image.  This was a common trait of my early astrophotography images.  The problem was, I focused entirely on the deep-sky object and completed disregarded the expanding stars around it.

These days, I use a layer mask to protect the stretching of the DSO from the background.  This way, I am able to boost the levels of an object (such as the Whale galaxy) and leave the size of the stars alone.  I also run 1 or 2 applications of the Make stars smaller action within the Astronomy Tools action set.

The Whale and Hockey Stick Galaxies

Whale Galaxy and Hockey Stick Galaxy

Wide field photo using an 80mm telescope of the Whale and Hockey Stick Galaxies

 

About the Whale Galaxy

NGC 4631 is an edge-on galaxy similar in size to our own Milky Way, located in the constellation Canes Venatici.  The Whale Galaxy has a small, yet bright, companion galaxy classified as NGC 4627 near its core.  This galaxy is difficult to observe visually in small telescopes as I experienced first hand!  This interested deep-sky object has been well photographed by amateur and professional astronomers alike.

I’d be interested to see someone image the Whale galaxy using a larger instrument such an SCT or large Newtonian Reflector. My telescope is always a reliable choice for a wide field view!